Case Name: Tesla Securities Litigation
Verdict: Not Liable for Losses
Claim Filing Deadline: Ah. well... 'Twas not to be.
He did it. Elon Musk pulled off the ultimate
stunt.
No, he did not to land a rover on the sun, and he
did not turn a profit at Twitter. He did something even harder:
Musk brought a securities litigation all the way
to trial and won a jury verdict.
In late January, trial began over what plaintiffs claimed was a pair of reckless Tweets on August 7, 2018:
"Am considering taking Tesla private at $420. Funding secured." The
second Tweet went: “Investor support is confirmed. Only reason why this is not
certain is that it’s contingent on a shareholder vote.”
Plaintiffs argued that these comments took
investors on a volatile and damaging ride. Prospects for a Tesla victory were
bleak. Given the poor track record of the few securities litigations that actually make
it to trial, the fact that the judge already ruled before the trial that the Tweets
were untrue, and the fact that Musk and Tesla had previously settled with the SEC for
$40 million over the same allegations, signs were pointing to a Tesla loss. And
a costly one at that.
However, the jury did not see a link between
Tesla’s market volatility and Musk’s Twitter posts. After only an hour of
deliberations, the jury found in favor of the defense.
Many investors—and D&O officers—might ask is
whether this case could set a precedent. More trials? More total victories for corporations?
Some defense attorneys have already thrown cold water on that prospect. Martin
Roth, an attorney at Kirkland & Ellis, told Law360, “I think [the verdict
is] an interesting data point, but I don't think it's going to change anyone's
analysis of a specific case based on their specific factual context."
The fact then remains that if a case survives a motion to dismiss, it is likely to settle. In the same Law360 (titled, by the way, "Musk Victory Unlikely To Move The Needle On Securities Trials") the author cited Cornerstone Research's analysis showing that 43% of all litigations filed since 1997 have been dismissed, which leaves a lot of potential for settlements. And given the cost of litigation, there will remain little desire to go to trial.
Chicago Clearing is tracking this case for any post-trial developments. Lead attorney for Tesla plaintiffs, Nicholas Porritt, told Reuters, “We are disappointed with the verdict and are considering next steps.”
If you have questions about this or any of the
hundreds of active securities litigations and settlements, please give us a
call at 312-204-6970.
Further Reading:
Case website:
https://www.teslasecuritieslitigation2018.com/
Commentary from the defense attorney perspective:
News:
https://www.nytimes.com/2023/02/03/business/elon-musk-tesla-investor-trial.html
Plaintiffs allege Alibaba's anti-competitive practices and a canceled IPO drove down stock price
CCC is Preparing Claims for Qualcomm Investors, Deadline Only Weeks Away
Plaintiffs allege Uber IPO was a "train wreck" for investors
Under Armour settles securities suit over allegations high inventories led to low profits
Apple, Boeing, and Weatherford Each Agree to Mega-Settlements
Alphabet Settles Securities Suit for $350 Million
Stock Loan Antitrust Settlement: A big opportunity should not be a big hassle
Alexion Pharmaceuticals Settles Securities Class Action over Alleged Illicit Sales Practices
Allegation that You’re in Bad Hands with Allstate Leads to $90 Million Settlement
Claim Forms Are Coming in the Payment Card Interchange Fee. CCC Can Help
Alexion Pharmaceuticals Settles Securities Class Action over Alleged Illicit Sales Practices
Allegation that You’re in Bad Hands with Allstate Leads to $90 Million Settlement
Claim Forms Are Coming in the Payment Card Interchange Fee. CCC Can Help
World Cup Bribery Scandal Leads to $95 Million Grupo Televisa Settlement
Case Profiles: The Kraft Heinz Company Securities Litigation and Fair Fund
Millions in Unsellable Inventory Leads to $109 Million Cardinal Health Securities Settlement
Securities Class Action Settlements in 2022 Hit Highest Levels in 15 Years
Micro Focus Settles Suit Alleging it Botched HPE Purchase for $107.5 Million
Wells Fargo Settles Securities Suit for $300 Million
Generic Drug Price-Fixing Allegations Lead to McKesson's $141 Million Settlement
Tesla Fends Off Securities Suit With Rare Victory in a Rare Trail
Elon Musk's Infamous 4-20 Tweet Leads to Rare Securities Litigation Trial
Barclays Massive Bond Over-Issuance Leads to a Securities Class Action
$809.5 Twitter Settlement Arrives at Last
How to Claim Your Piece of the $5.54 Billion Payment Card Settlement
Anti-competition Probes and Overexpansion Lead to Multiple Class Actions Against Amazon
How CCC Helps Investors Participate in Foreign Financial Litigations
Cryptic Tweet Leads to $40 Million Tesla Fair Fund
Nielsen Holdings, Market Share King, Settles Securities Suit over Its Own Market Troubles
Infrastructure Cost Overruns Leads to $129 Million Granite Construction Securities Settlement
Petrobras Fair Fund Offers $85.32 Million in Relief to Harmed Investors
Barclays and JPMorgan Settle Mexican Bond Antitrust Litigation for $20,700,000
Deadline Is Soon for the $27.5 Million GreenSky Securities Settlement
Symantec, now known as NortonLifeLock, Settles Securities Suit for $70 Million
Corrections Corporation of America Settles Securities Litigation over the Safety of Its Prisons
Twitter Securities Class Action Ends with an $809.5 Million Settlement
Honest Company, Boston Beer Company, Waterdrop, and Longeveron Face Securities Class Action Suits
Door Manufacturer JELD-WEN Settles Securities Suit Related to Price-Fixing Scandal
Allergan Settles Securities Suit Related to Price-Fixing Scandal for $130 Million
Nikola Trucks Scandal Leads to Securities Suit and a Criminal Indictment of Its Founder
Why Every Investor Needs a Class Action Claim Filing Partner
Willis Towers Watson Settles a Pair of Merger-Related Suits for $90 Million
Snap Settles Two Suits in State and Federal Court for $187,500,000
Another MBS Settlement: $275 Million Morgan Stanley Fair Fund
Santander Consumer Holdings USA Securities Class Action Provides $39 Million to Investors
Avon Settles Suit Over Brazilian Market Practices
The LIBOR Bondholder Settlement: Several Big Problems and One Simple Solution
Snap, Parent Company of Snapchat, Settles Suit Over Allegations They Understated Competition
Eight Years in the Making, First Solar Settlement Provides $350 Million to Harmed Investors
Coronavirus Related Securities Class Actions Arrive
GSE Bonds Antitrust Litigation Update
Equifax Data Breach Leads to Securities Litigation Settlement
Wells Fargo Fair Fund to Provide $500 Million to Investors
NERA Year-End Report for 2019: More complaints, bigger backlog of unresolved cases
GSE Bonds Claim Filing Deadline Extended to February 28, 2020
404 South Wells St., Suite 600,
Chicago, IL 60607 – United States
Phone: (312) 204-6970
Email:
info@chicagoclearing.com
Chicago Clearing Corporation is the
industry leader in class-action services.
2024 © Chicago Clearing Corporation. All rights reserved. Terms and conditions