Cryptic Tweet Leads to $40 Million Tesla Fair Fund

Elon Musk's Social Media Post Led to SEC Investigation and Class Action

Case Name: Tesla Fair Fund

Settlement Fund: $40,000,000

Claim Filing Deadline: September 17, 2022

Class Period: 8/7/2018 -- 8/8/2018

It is one of the most specific class periods on record for a securities settlement: investors may participate in the Tesla Fair Fund if they purchased or acquired the company’s common stock, "between 12:48:16 PM EDT on August 7, 2018 and 4:00 PM EDT on August 8, 2018."


The end time is clear—4:00 Eastern is when the closing bell rings on the NASDAQ, where TSLA shares are traded. But what happened at precisely sixteen seconds after the forty-eighth minute of the noon hour on the seventh day of August, 2018?


As you may recall, the future owner (maybe) of Twitter was making cryptic comments on Twitter.


"Is Elon Musk serious?" is now a common question as the world watches his attempt to buy the social media company. But during the 48th minute of noon, 8/7/2018, investors were left to parse the meaning of, "Am considering taking Tesla private at $420. Funding secured."


Would he really pay $420 per share, which was a 20 percent premium at the time? Or was it because 420, when pronounced four-twenty, is slang for the supposedly optimum time of day to smoke marijuana?


The answer may be a little of both: Musk thought a 20% premium was fair, and the price was a sophomoric gag. As plaintiffs point out in a related class action, "Musk believed that 20% was a ‘standard premium’ in going-private transactions. Although the precise calculation equaled $419.49, Musk rounded the price up to $420 per share because he thought his girlfriend at the time, Claire Elise Boucher (also known as ‘Grimes’), would find it funny due to the significance of the number to marijuana users."


Over the next few days, Tesla investors went on a "Magic Carpet Ride," as the price went from $343 at open on August 7 to $379.59 at close, down to $370.34 at the close on August 8, and then $352.45 on August 9. (We reference Steppenwolf here because we do not know any Grimes songs.)

The Securities and Exchange Commission was not amused. The SEC's Enforcement Division began investigating immediately, and by September 27, 2018 had filed charges. Two days later the SEC announced a settlement requiring both Tesla and Musk to pay $20 million each, which three and a half years later comes in the form of this $40 million Fair Fund.


The class action based on the now-infamous Tweet is still pending in the Northern District of California, (3:18-cv-04865), and one of hundreds of unresolved cases which CCC is tracking.

More News from the Class Action World

Cornerstone Research has released its yearly securities class action litigation report and found dramatic increases in the number of settlements and in the average settlement pools. (The link to the full report is below.)

Cornerstone focused on federal securities class actions, specifically cases al... Read More

Case Name: Micro Focus

Settlement Fund: $107,500,000

Claim Filing Deadline: 5/30/2022

Class: All persons who purchased or acquired Micro Focus American Depositary Shares (“ADSs”) issued in connection with the Merger of Micro Focus and the software business segment of HPE (the “Merger”), which was c... Read More

Case Name: Wells Fargo 2018 Litigation

Settlement Fund: $300,000,000

Claim Filing Deadline: TBD

Class Period: 11/3/2016 -- 8/3/2017

Chicago Clearing Corporation is tracking a new $300 settlement with Wells Fargo. As of today (2/23/23) proof of claim forms and notices are not yet available, but recovery could be substanti... Read More

Case Name: McKesson

Read More

Case Name: Tesla Securities Litigation

Read More

Case Name: Tesla Securities Litigation

Read More

Case Nam... Read More

In the final days of summer 2021, Twitter announced it had settled a securities suit first launched in 2016. Typically when parties announce the resolution of a securities class action, the settlement materials are posted to the court docket promptly, often within a month. Shortly after that the judge signs a preliminary approval order, ... Read More

Payment Card Interchange Fee and Merchant Discount Antitrust Litigation, MDL 1720

Read More